Sponsoring Organization: Council of Editors of Learned JournalsAward Level: Best Special Issue | Award Year: 2025Winner: Leviathan: A Journal of Melville Studies, Melville In Public (Volume 25, Number 3, October 2023)
Sponsoring Organization: Lutheran QuarterlyAward Level: Lutheran Quarterly Essay Prize | Award Year: 2024Winner: John W. Hoyum, "Robert Jenson and the Dogmatic Location of Culture"
Sponsoring Organization: portal: Libraries and the AcademyAward Level: Johns Hopkins University Press Award for Best Article | Award Year: 2024Winner: Kristin Antelman, "Content Warnings and Censorship"